NFL Odds and News: Rodgers’ Steelers Debut

Share News

NFL Odds and News

Aaron Rodgers’ Steelers Debut: Can Pittsburgh Contend in 2025?

The 2025 NFL season has brought one of its biggest headlines before a snap has even been taken: Aaron Rodgers is now the quarterback for the Pittsburgh Steelers. NFL betting markets have already begun adjusting, and NFL odds surrounding the AFC playoff picture are shifting in real time. 

As the 41-year-old prepares for a fresh start in the Steel City, fans and bettors alike are wondering how much of an impact Rodgers can realistically make. With a new offensive coordinator and a reshaped offense, the season feels like a true crossroads for the franchise.

The Steelers hope this move transforms them from fringe contenders to a legitimate playoff threat. Now that the NFL Draft has passed and Rodgers is officially locked in as the starting quarterback, Pittsburgh enters the 2025 season with heightened expectations and intense scrutiny.

Rodgers’ Ceiling and Pittsburgh’s Playoff Picture

Aaron Rodgers doesn’t need to be an MVP for the Steelers to benefit from his presence, but he does need to be close to it. While many think Rodgers’ best days are behind him, if Pittsburgh gets even 80 percent of vintage Rodgers, the team becomes a 9- or 10-win squad capable of hanging in the playoff race through December.

Of course, playoff success is primarily determined by matchups. The Steelers have struggled against the AFC’s top-tier teams, the Kansas City Chiefs, the Baltimore Ravens, and the Buffalo Bills. Last season, defensive coordinator Teryl Austin acknowledged that the Steelers struggled specifically when facing Baltimore, calling it a persistent challenge. 

Rodgers alone likely doesn’t push Pittsburgh past those powerhouses. Still, if the Steelers land a more favorable opponent, such as Houston, Denver, Cincinnati, or the Chargers, their NFL odds of advancing increase significantly.

Who’s Really Calling the Plays?

Rodgers’ fit in Arthur Smith’s offense has been a significant topic of discussion. While some expected philosophical clashes, their systems share more overlap than many realize. Rodgers comes from the West Coast offense under Mike McCarthy and the Shanahan-based system with Matt LaFleur, both of which mirror elements of Smith’s style. Smith’s history includes coaching under LaFleur and Ken Whisenhunt, who also drew heavily from West Coast principles.

Expect Pittsburgh to implement a quick passing game to maximize Rodgers’ release speed and minimize exposure to hits. Shanahan-style zone runs and play-action setups will form the backbone of the offense. A heavy dose of 4×1 receiver formations is also likely—an approach Rodgers thrived in with the Green Bay Packers.

Autonomy at the Line of Scrimmage

In Atlanta, Smith was reportedly unhappy with Russell Wilson’s tendency to change plays. But Rodgers commands a different level of respect. Pittsburgh’s staff appears more willing to let Rodgers make line-of-scrimmage adjustments, especially with route tweaks via hand signals. 

While Smith might ask for structure in certain moments, Rodgers’ football IQ is a key reason he was signed. Limiting his field vision and instinctual decision-making would go against the point of the acquisition.

The Steelers are gambling that Rodgers can compensate for aging legs with elite pre-snap reads and decision-making. If they’re going all-in, Rodgers must have the keys to the offense.

Statistical Outlook: A Realistic Projection

Rodgers has thrown 25 or more touchdowns in every season where he played 15 or more games. That history makes the 25-TD over/under line seem right on the money. 

Assuming he stays healthy, the over is likely. But yardage is another story. Hitting 4,000 yards might be asking too much. Rodgers eclipsed 3,897 last year, but it took one of the league’s highest pass attempt totals. Pittsburgh is expected to run a more balanced offense.

Last season, Steelers QBs combined for 3,264 passing yards. If Rodgers stays healthy and starts all 17 games, reaching a yardage range of 3,700–3,900 seems fair, slightly above last year’s production but still below elite benchmarks.

WR Depth Still a Concern

The Steelers’ wide receiver room remains thin despite roster moves. While rumors continue about potential trades, including a reunion with Allen Lazard, Pittsburgh may wait to see how camp unfolds. 

There’s some potential in Roman Wilson and Calvin Austin III as developmental prospects, while Robert Woods adds veteran presence, though questions remain about his reliability.

Pittsburgh used more 13 personnel (one back, three tight ends) than any other team last year, suggesting the solution may come via tight end contributions instead of wideout additions. However, one injury to DK Metcalf could destabilize the group, as evidenced by George Pickens’ injury last season.

The Offensive Line: Can It Hold?

Rodgers’ most significant vulnerability may be his protection. In 2024, he posted a league-worst -0.20 EPA per dropback against the blitz (minimum 300 attempts). Now, he’ll be shielded by two inexperienced tackles: Broderick Jones and rookie Troy Fautanu. 

Jones has played chiefly the right side and enters his third season under pressure. Fautanu, meanwhile, spent most of college on the left and has just one NFL start. That duo will be key in protecting a 41-year-old quarterback.

Interior line strength will come from Isaac Seumalo, Zach Frazier, and Mason McCormick. Behind the starters, names like Max Scharping and Calvin Anderson round out a unit that might require reinforcements before Week 1.

Defense Remains the X-Factor

The defensive unit, which finished in the top 10 for three straight years, could again be the team’s anchor. Still, there are wildcards. Joey Porter Jr. must reduce penalties. Darius Slay, if he holds up physically, can help Pittsburgh play more man coverage, potentially unlocking Minkah Fitzpatrick’s playmaking. On the defensive line, the trio of Keeanu Benton, Cameron Heyward, and Derrick Harmon is solid, but depth falls off rapidly.

Injuries to the defensive line or secondary could force midseason acquisitions or major scheme adjustments. Pittsburgh’s playoff hopes, as their NFL odds improvement aspirations likely depend on this unit staying healthy and dominant.

Mike Tomlin’s Timeline and Rodgers’ Future

This season isn’t a make-or-break year for head coach Mike Tomlin, at least not in the eyes of ownership. Despite a playoff win drought since 2016, Tomlin recently received a contract extension through 2027, signaling long-term faith from the Rooney family.

Still, public perception could sour if the team wins 10 games only to suffer another early playoff exit. Rodgers’ presence raises expectations. Falling short again would likely spark renewed debate about Tomlin’s postseason shortcomings, even if his regular-season consistency continues.

As for Rodgers’ future? Most signs indicate that this is a one-year rental. If he performs well but not spectacularly, expect Pittsburgh to draft a quarterback in the 2026 NFL Draft. But if Rodgers pushes the team into a deep playoff run or outperforms expectations, a second season isn’t out of the question. That would require quick commitment from both sides and a draft position that makes landing a top QB unlikely.

A Coin Flip Season

Pittsburgh is firmly in the NFL’s middle tier. Rodgers improves the team’s odds in tight games and provides a proven leader. But they’re still behind AFC giants like Kansas City and Baltimore. If healthy and clicking, the Steelers can beat any of the other playoff hopefuls.

For NFL betting fans, the innovative approach may be to monitor early-season performance and live bet based on matchups and momentum. NFL odds will shift quickly as Rodgers shows what he still has left.

Expect a playoff berth fight, a stats line that hovers just above average, and a city holding its breath with every Rodgers dropback. Pittsburgh has bet big on Rodgers, and the 2025 season will reveal whether the gamble pays off.