MLB All Star Game Odds: Team by Team Betting Analysis

MLBNEWS
July 4, 2025

MLB All-Star Game Odds

Explosive All-Star Picks Unveiled: First-Timers, Fan Favorites, and Outrageous Snubs!

 

The 2025 MLB All-Star Game starting lineups have been unveiled, and they’re igniting seismic waves across MLB Betting boards and fantasy circles alike. With MLB All-Star Game Odds shifting following a mix of fan favorites, dramatic comebacks, and unthinkable first-time selections, this year’s All-Star starters are unlike any in recent memory. 

The announcement delivers plenty for bettors and fans to digest, as MLB Lines react to the fresh stardom of rising rookies and the return of old legends. Among the highlights are a controversial choice at AL shortstop, a National League outfield featuring an electrifying rookie, and multiple nods for both the Dodgers and Tigers.

 

Ohtani Headlines NL Chaos, Crow-Armstrong Rockets to Stardom

 

The most votes in the National League belonged to Shohei Ohtani, continuing his unprecedented record-breaking career. Although his mound appearances have been limited to three starts, his bat is driving MVP-level impact. 

Ohtani leads the league in home runs, slugging, runs scored, and is tops among all qualified NL hitters in weighted runs created plus. Toss in 11 stolen bases and a near-identical slash line to his previous MVP seasons, and it’s no surprise fans sent him to his fifth consecutive All-Star Game.

Joining him in the NL outfield is Pete Crow-Armstrong, making his All-Star debut. The Cubs’ center fielder has been a defensive demon and an offensive sparkplug, blasting 21 home runs and racking up top-five fWAR in the majors. His elite sprint speed and defensive runs saved have made him the total package, and he’s a massive part of why the Chicago Cubs lead the NL Central.

A big surprise was Ronald Acuña Jr.’s selection. Despite playing only 35 games due to his return from knee surgery, Acuña was voted in as a starter. That might shock some, but the Braves slugger homered in his first two games back and owns per-at-bat numbers rivaled only by Aaron Judge. His limited playing time hasn’t stopped him from producing like a top-tier bat.

Francisco Lindor, while no stranger to All-Star nods, is enjoying his first-ever starting selection. Being a model of consistency throughout his career with the New York Mets, he has reached Cooperstown levels of achievement. For the first time in his New York tenure, he’ll finally take the field as a starter.

 

Judge Dominates AL Voting, Rookie Shocker at Shortstop

 

Aaron Judge led all players in fan votes, surpassing even Ohtani. The Yankees’ captain is in his best season to date. Judge currently leads the majors in batting average, OBP, slugging, and owns a 6.5 fWAR that exceeds nearly every player’s entire 2024 output. 

This marks his seventh career All-Star nod and fifth straight start, and it’s a centerpiece for anyone analyzing MLB Odds tied to New York’s second-half playoff push.

One of the biggest shocks from the American League lineup is at shortstop, where 23-year-old Jacob Wilson earned a starting spot in his rookie season. The Athletics infielder surged past MVP candidates like Bobby Witt Jr. and Gunnar Henderson in fan voting. 

Wilson, who plays in Sacramento, is only the third Oakland position player to be elected as a starter since 1993. He’s second in the majors in batting average and a front-runner for AL Rookie of the Year, but his rise from obscurity to All-Star starter remains the story shaking up the AL.

Another jaw-dropping choice is Tigers outfielder Javier Báez, whose All-Star career seemed buried after two lackluster seasons in Detroit. Báez had played below replacement level in 2024, with many predicting a midseason release. 

Instead, he’s posted a 120 OPS+, second only to his MVP-run season in 2018, and edged out names like Julio Rodriguez and Byron Buxton to claim a starting spot. Now an All-Star outfielder, Báez becomes the year’s most unexpected comeback story.

 

Feel-Good Stories and First-Time Fireworks Shake Betting Angles

 

Cal Raleigh’s long-overdue All-Star debut is another highlight. Known for elite framing and clutch power, Raleigh has been among baseball’s best all-around catchers for years but never got All-Star recognition, until now. 

This season, he’s taken it to another level, ranking second behind Judge in fWAR. It’s not just a well-earned nod; it’s a potential betting indicator of Seattle’s offensive evolution.

Ryan O’Hearn, 31 and in his eighth season, rounds out the list of AL first-timers. The Orioles‘ designated hitter is on pace for a career-best campaign after a rocky five-year stint with the Kansas City Royals. He ranks 16th in MLB in wRC+ and has outperformed every other full-time DH in the AL. 

If Rafael Devers hadn’t been traded to the Giants, O’Hearn might not have cracked the starting nine, but now he’s one of the most inspiring stories on the roster and a wildcard in MLB Lines as Baltimore pushes for playoff leverage.

Crow-Armstrong joins this feel-good wave in the NL, going from defensive specialist to all-around phenom. His presence in the All-Star Game is a testament to the Cubs’ development pipeline and their threat level for postseason contention, something MLB Betting markets will not ignore.

 

Who Got Snubbed? The Missing Pieces Stir Debate

 

The All-Star selections always spark controversy, and 2025 is no different. Bobby Witt Jr.’s exclusion from the AL starting roster is the most glaring omission. With a near-identical fWAR to Jeremy Pena and a stronger profile than Wilson in power and speed, Witt was expected to dominate the vote. 

Pena, the fWAR leader at shortstop, might have been the statistical favorite, but he’s injured, which likely dropped him from contention. Still, Wilson’s leapfrogging both turned AL shortstop into the most contentious pick of the cycle.

In the NL, rookie James Wood and breakout star Corbin Carroll were both overlooked in a crowded outfield ballot dominated by Dodgers and Acuña’s popularity. Wood ranks in the top 10 in overall fWAR, while Carroll isn’t far behind. San Diego Padres slugger Fernando Tatis Jr. sits at 3.4 fWAR and also missed the cut. 

While all three could make the bench, their exclusion from the starting lineup raises eyebrows and could present second-half betting value for teams flying under the public radar.

Another notable snub is Pete Alonso. The Mets’ first baseman arguably outperformed Freddie Freeman, but lost the fan vote in what was a razor-thin margin. Similar whispers surround Trea Turner, who was neck-and-neck with Lindor for shortstop. These calls won’t shift the All-Star Game odds dramatically, but they deepen the intrigue heading into the second half.

 

All-Star Arms: Who Should Take the Mound First?

 

Pitching picks will be made official the week of the game, but signs are pointing toward two dominant aces: Zack Wheeler of the Phillies and Tarik Skubal of the Tigers. Wheeler, a two-time All-Star, has struck out more batters than anyone in the NL starter pool and boasts a WHIP lower than Skenes. If chosen, it would be the first time he opens the Midsummer Classic, having faced only one hitter in his two previous appearances.

On the AL side, Skubal looks like a lock. Last year’s unanimous Cy Young winner has somehow improved, leading the majors with a mind-blowing 9.86 strikeout-to-walk ratio and a 0.83 WHIP that would make Bob Gibson jealous. He was first out of the bullpen last year, but he should be the first man on the mound this time around. The ripple effect on the All-Star Game odds, involving both the Phillies and Tigers’ rotation outlooks, will be immediate.

 

Betting Fallout and Second-Half Implications

 

The All-Star selections have transformed the betting landscape. Rookie explosions, surprising veterans, and snub-driven motivation are all elements that shape MLB Betting trends as the season rolls toward October. From Wilson’s Cinderella rise to Crow-Armstrong’s electric debut, this year’s All-Star Game doesn’t just reflect the league’s best, it forecasts who will shift futures markets.

For those tracking the All-Star Game Odds towards the day, understanding these selections isn’t trivia; it’s strategy. Expect bettors to back players like O’Hearn and Skubal more aggressively. And don’t be surprised if under-the-radar names like James Wood or Bobby Witt Jr. respond in a big way in the season’s second half, with revenge arcs fueling their climb back into the spotlight.

The midsummer classic isn’t just a celebration anymore. It’s a warning shot for what’s coming.

 

Score up to $1,500
on your first deposit

50% Welcome Bonus

Join the BUSR Experience. Stream LIVE all major sport leagues, enjoy live in-game moments with live betting, exclusive team props, and season futures. You control your winnings with our new Early Cash-Out option—no need to wait for game endings. Enjoy 24-hour payouts, dive into over 400 casino games, and access to exclusive lines and boosted odds.