Speed vs. Stamina: What Wins Preakness Stakes Historically?

HORSE RACING
May 12, 2025

Preakness Stakes Betting Analysis

Speed vs. Stamina: What Wins Preakness Stakes Historically?

 

As the 2025 Preakness Stakes approaches, fans and bettors are examining one of the longest-standing debates in horse racing betting: is speed or stamina the key to winning the second jewel of the Triple Crown? 

The Pimlico Race Course offers a unique challenge, and understanding past outcomes is critical when evaluating Preakness Stakes odds and building innovative Preakness Stakes betting strategies.

The Preakness, run at 1 3/16 miles, is shorter than the Kentucky Derby but still a test of class and conditioning. Post position and running style both play vital roles in shaping the outcome. But over the years, patterns have emerged that suggest which approach, early speed or late stamina, tends to have the upper hand.

 

Track Profile and Strategic Positioning

 

Unlike Churchill Downs, Pimlico has tighter turns and a shorter homestretch. That makes early positioning critical, especially in larger fields. Historically, horses with tactical speed that can get into a good spot without using too much energy have fared well. However, that doesn’t always mean gate-to-wire winners dominate.

A blend of speed and stamina has been the winning formula in recent decades. Horses that sit just off the leaders, known as stalkers or pressers, often make their move on the final turn and hold off deep closers who run out of real estate in the short stretch.

 

Past Winners: A Mixed Blueprint

 

Looking back at recent Preakness champions, both styles have found success. Justify (2018) and American Pharoah (2015) used forward positioning to control the pace and win handily. War of Will (2019), who had a good tactical trip, stayed close to the lead and took advantage when it opened up. 

Swiss Skydiver (2020), a rare filly winner, used speed and tenacity to outduel Kentucky Derby winner Authentic. On the other hand, Rombauer (2021) came from mid-pack and closed firmly, showcasing the impact of stamina and late acceleration.

These winners shared versatility and the ability to respond to the race shape. A horse that can settle, adapt, and fire late is valuable. For horse racing betting, this means avoiding one-dimensional picks and favoring those with proven adaptability.

 

The Role of the Draw

 

Post position also plays a role in shaping which trait holds an edge. Inside posts often favor speed horses who can establish position early, while wide draws can hamper closers who need to save ground for a big late run. Pimlico’s smaller field than the Derby lessens some of the extremes seen at Churchill Downs.

If a frontrunner draws inside and gets a clean break, he might control the pace and be tough to reel in. But a stamina-based runner with a good jockey can also sit just off the speed and pounce when others begin to tire. The key is a horse’s ability to move without being compromised by post placement or traffic.

 

How to Bet the Balance

 

When analyzing how to bet on Preakness, it is essential to look at past performance beyond just finishing position. Dig into race replays, pace figures, and how horses perform at different points of the race. Did a horse finish strong after a wide trip? Did another fade late after setting the pace?

Preakness Stakes betting should factor in recent races where the trip was compromised or showcased grit. Horses that have shown fight late in tough spots tend to perform well at Pimlico.

Jockey decisions and pace scenarios also weigh heavily. A competent rider who knows when to ask for a run can make all the difference, especially in a race where margins are slim. Look for horses with both the numbers and the narrative to support them.

 

Blending Traits Wins

 

No hard rule says speed or stamina wins the Preakness Stakes. History shows both styles can win under the right circumstances. The most successful contenders possess a balanced toolkit, an early foot to stay in touch, and the stamina to finish.

For bettors, the ideal pick is not the fastest horse or the deepest closer but the most complete package. To make the most informed decisions and see updated Preakness Stakes odds and insights, visit our racebook before race day.

 

Score up to $1,500
on your first deposit

50% Welcome Bonus

Join the BUSR Experience. Stream LIVE all major sport leagues, enjoy live in-game moments with live betting, exclusive team props, and season futures. You control your winnings with our new Early Cash-Out option—no need to wait for game endings. Enjoy 24-hour payouts, dive into over 400 casino games, and access to exclusive lines and boosted odds.